How to compare a method to a reference method?

How to compare a method to a reference method?

When measuring a method against a reference method using many items the average bias is an estimate of bias that is averaged over all the items. Difference plot (Bland-Altman plot) A difference plot shows the differences in measurements between two methods, and any relationship between the differences and true values.

Which is the best definition of average bias?

Average bias Bias is a measure of a systematic measurement error, the component of measurement error that remains constant in replicate measurements on the same item. When measuring a method against a reference method using many items the average bias is an estimate of bias that is averaged over all the items.

Is the bias between two measurements random or proportional?

Bias between two measurements can be random, proportional and constant. Bland-Altman plots showing random, proportional and constant bias are presented in Figs. 4 a-c. Confidence limits of the bias depend on the number of measurements and the variability of the measurements.

Which is the key to a successful method comparison?

The key to the successful method comparison is therefore a well-designed and carefully planned experiment. The question to be answered by the method comparison is whether two methods could be used interchangeably without affecting patient results and patient outcome.

What does regression of the differences on the true value mean?

Regression of the differences on the true value describes the relationship between the methods. Limits of agreement (LoA) Limits of agreement estimate the interval within which a proportion of the differences between measurements lie. Mountain plot (folded CDF plot)

How to describe the relationship between the methods?

Fit Y on X Regression of Y on X describes the linear relationship between the methods. Linearity Linearity is the assumption that the relationship between the methods is linear. Residual plot A residual plot shows the difference between the measured values and the predicted values against the true values.

How is the percent difference between two values calculated?

Percent difference is calculated as the difference between two values, divided by the average of the two values, expressed in terms of percentage.