What is an editorial review process?
The first step in the manuscript review process is editorial review. During this stage, reviewers evaluate how well the submission fits the scope of set criteria. Accept the submission and send it to peer review. Request a revised submission.
How long does an editorial decision take?
Editorial Decisions The time to render a first decision averages about 43 days, but times vary depending on how long it takes for the editor to receive and assess reviews. The editor considers reviewer feedback and their own evaluation of the manuscript in order to reach a decision.
How do you start an editorial review?
The review often proceeds as follows:
- Read the draft for content: coverage and organization.
- Make marginal notes.
- Place potential problems in context.
- Write down your recommendations.
- Read for punctuation and mechanics.
What is e publishing process?
E-publishing in general is a computer-based way of publishing content. In e-publishing, the publication is digitally done, with no need for printing. E-publishing is similar to the traditional publishing process, minus the step of printing the material.
What is an editorial decision?
An editorial decision is made on the basis of the reviewers’ reports and all the other information that the editor has related to that submission, and communicated to the author.
How does the editorial process work in Smashing Magazine?
For a very technical article, or something outside of the core knowledge of the editor they will request help from our review panel. In that case, the editor will take their feedback and present it to you along with their own thoughts. You will then have time to make any necessary revisions that come out of the discussions. A Final Draft!
How does the editorial process work in a journal?
The editorial team will respect these requests as long as they do not interfere with the objective and thorough assessment of the submission. If the journal has a reviewer board, these reviewers could apply to review a submitted manuscript should the authors agree with this option during submission.
Can a guest editor access the editorial process?
The Guest Editor will be unable to access the review process except in their role as author. Similarly, Editors-in-Chief, or other Editorial Board members are not able to access the review process of their manuscript except in their role as author.
How are disputes settled in the editorial process?
Disputes on the validity of research reported in published papers can be settled by the Editorial Board. For disputes around authorship, data ownership, author misconduct, etc., where necessary, we will refer to external organizations such as a university ethics committee.