Can a code review be off topic on Stack Overflow?

Can a code review be off topic on Stack Overflow?

Nothing in the Stack Overflow rules justifies such a custom reason, and sloppy reasoning perpetuates inappropriate referrals. Not all questions about analyzing code are off-topic on Stack Overflow, and not all code review requests are on-topic on Code Review. Instead, vote to close as too broad or primarily opinion-based.

Why are there close votes on code review?

The close votes or downvotes make the Code Review community look hostile, when we are just doing our duty to inform the poster that the question is unanswerable. The original asker may become frustrated that Code Review answers are “missing the point of the question”, because on Code Review all questions are considered to be open-ended.

What makes a good code review a nitpick?

Nitpicks are are unimportant comments, where the code could be merged without even addressing these. These could be things like variable declarations being in alphabetical order, unit tests following a certain structure, or brackets being on the same line. Good code reviews make it clear when changes are unimportant nitpicks.

How to ask a good question on code review?

The Stack Overflow Help Center doesn’t say that code reviews are explicitly off-topic there, so don’t migrate for the sake of migration. Before posting a question on Code Review, read How do I ask a good question?, which covers the common reasons for questions being poorly received on Code Review. Does the question title need to be changed?

When does code review come before unit testing?

Sometimes the code review happens before the unit testing but usually only when the code reviewer is really swamped and that’s the only time he or she can do it. Share Improve this answer

Why do you need to do a code review?

This is accomplished, in part, with code review. Code review helps developers learn the code base, as well as help them learn new technologies and techniques that grow their skill sets. So, what exactly is a code review?

How to join the code review Stack Exchange?

Code Review Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for peer programmer code reviews. It only takes a minute to sign up.

How often should you do a code review?

Keep the reviews small (200-400 LOC). Any more than that, and reviewer effectiveness is greatly decreased. Expect to review 300-500 LOC/hour. If you follow this guideline and the previous one, code reviews should last no longer than 90 minutes. Keep managers out of code reviews.

How to ask code review questions on Stack Overflow?

To help reviewers give you better answers, Code Review questions should include a description of what the code does. The more you tell us about what your code does and the purpose of it, the easier it will be for reviewers to help you. So what questions do you want? On all cross-posted questions, please add comments with mutual links.

Why are some questions closed on code review?

The most common reason for questions to be closed as off-topic on Code Review is that the code simply does not do what it is meant to do. Code Review is not about fixing bugs, and it is not a place to go for help adding a new feature to your program. Questions asking “Does this code work?”

Why is a code review a bad idea?

There are many reasons this is a bad idea, but here are two of the most important: External reviews catch problems that would affect everyone if the code were merged into the main repository. The process of merging code causes the developer to feel that the work is done, and it’s time to go on to the next thing.

What are the two types of code review?

The first is known as peer review and the second is external review. The code review process doesn’t begin working instantaneously (especially with external review), and our process is far from being perfect — although we have done some serious research around the topic [3]. So, we are always open to suggestions for improvement.

What do you need to know about code review?

Code Review is a question and answer site for seeking peer review of your code. We are working together to improve the skills of programmers worldwide by taking working code and making it better. If you have a working piece of code from your project and are looking for open-ended feedback in the following areas: